The Real Math: How Many Bookings (and Dollars) You Lose Without a “BookNow” Button

So how much business are you actually missing? Let’s do simple, conservative math.

A Realistic Scenario

• 500 visitors per month to your website or social profiles
• Only 5–10% take the time to call or text
• The rest? Gone

Now compare that to online booking behavior.

Industry benchmarks show that instant booking can double or triple conversion rates for experience-based businesses. When guests can book immediately, fewer drop off.

What That Looks Like for a Captain

Let’s say:

• Average trip price: $800
• You miss just 2 bookings per month due to friction

That’s:

• $1,600/month
• $19,200/year

And that doesn’t include repeat trips, referrals, or multi-year customers.

The our Captain, We Need to Talk eBook highlights that repeat customers are 5–10x more valuable than new leads, yet most captains never capture their customer data when bookings happen off-platform or through third-party marketplaces.

Why Marketplaces Don’t Solve This

Many captains assume listing on a marketplace fixes the problem.

But marketplaces:

• Take 20–30% commissions
• Owns your customer data
• Turn your business into a one-time transaction

You may get the booking, but you lose the relationship.

The Compounding Effect

Without direct booking:

• No customer list
• No automated follow-ups
• No repeat business engine

Each missed booking isn’t just lost revenue. It’s lost future revenue.

Download Captain, We Need to Talk

See real-world cost comparisons and why owning the booking matters more than generating leads.
Download the eBook Here